Alabama's Upset Loss to Vanderbilt: A Grade Breakdown
The Crimson Tide's 2023 season took a shocking turn in Nashville, as Vanderbilt pulled off an improbable upset, handing Alabama their first loss of the season. This loss, which ended a streak of 29 straight wins against unranked opponents, has raised questions about the Tide's ability to defend their national title. Let's take a look at the key areas of the game and assign grades for Alabama's performance:
Offense (C-)
The good: While the offense struggled overall, Jalen Milroe did flash some potential, especially in the run game. He accounted for 118 rushing yards and a touchdown, showcasing his mobility and athleticism.
The bad: The passing game was incredibly inefficient, with Milroe completing just 9 of 20 passes for 111 yards and two interceptions. The receivers struggled to create separation, and the offensive line struggled to protect Milroe, resulting in numerous sacks.
The ugly: Alabama's lack of explosive plays was particularly alarming. They were unable to consistently move the ball down the field, failing to generate any momentum and leaving the defense on the field for too long.
Defense (D)
The good: The defense managed to limit the Vanderbilt offense for a portion of the game, particularly in the first half. They forced a couple of turnovers, including a crucial interception by Malachi Moore.
The bad: Vanderbilt's rushing attack exposed Alabama's defensive weakness, consistently gaining yardage on the ground. The Tide struggled to contain the Commodores' running backs, allowing them to churn out long drives and control the tempo of the game.
The ugly: The most alarming aspect was the defense's inability to make crucial stops when they were needed. Vanderbilt converted numerous crucial third downs and extended drives, putting immense pressure on the offense. This lack of discipline and execution proved costly.
Special Teams (C)
The good: Alabama's special teams performance was mostly uneventful, which is a positive in itself given the struggles in other areas. The kickers were accurate, and the coverage units performed adequately.
The bad: The lack of a big play in the kicking game could have been a difference-maker in a close game. The punt return unit didn't offer much threat and allowed Vanderbilt to maintain good field position.
The ugly: No major blunders, but the special teams performance didn't offer any decisive impact in the game.
Coaching (F)
The good: It's difficult to find any positives in the coaching performance. The play-calling on offense was uninspired and predictable. Defensive adjustments seemed to come too late, and the team's overall preparation for the game was clearly inadequate.
The bad: The coaching staff failed to adjust to Vanderbilt's game plan and allowed them to exploit their weaknesses. The lack of game-day adjustments and overall execution was a major contributing factor to the loss.
The ugly: The coaching staff seemed unprepared for a game against a supposedly inferior opponent. This lack of focus and attention to detail was evident in the team's performance.
Overall (D)
This loss was a wake-up call for Alabama, exposing their vulnerability and lack of consistency. The team must quickly address their weaknesses and find answers for the upcoming season. The loss to Vanderbilt raises significant questions about the team's potential for the rest of the season and their ability to compete for a national title.
